I just happened to catch Tim Ryan’s interview with CNN’s Don Lemon last night and...even more so than his comments about Nancy Pelosi, the particular comment in the headline pissed me the fuck off.
First of all, Ryan is from Ohio and I’m from Michigan...’Nuff said on that...but let’s get to the comment in question.
His comment here valorizing blue-collar workers ticked me off.
First of all, I was raised, in part, by my (now deceased) uncle who worked for the Chrysler plant on Lynch near Mound Road in Detroit for decades...and retired from there.
Uncle E. used to bring his football betting slips home for me to fill out.
I have a number of other family members that worked blue-collar jobs; usually for Ford.
I have other family members that did clerical jobs, professional jobs, were managers...even entrepreneurs...and other things.
They all worked damn hard. They all had to come home from work and, as Mr. Ryan said, “take a shower” (shoot, if you didn’t, folks in my family will talk about you).
As an adult, I have pretty much the same economic mix of friends. They all (well, most of them, anyway) work damn hard and most of them are good at what they do.
I’ve done my share of blue-collar work (which I’m pretty useless at, actually, but if it pays the bills...). Most of my working life, I’ve worked in administrative support of various professionals.
These people work hard. If the entrance requirements for their position required a college degree, they worked damn hard for that.
I still remember the time that an old boss of mine had to pull me in and give me a stack of financial paperwork and a laptop to take home so that I could help her reach a crushing deadline.
Just because you’re a “white-collar worker” doesn’t mean that you have it easy or that your job is less stressful or that you don’t have trouble paying bills or that you didn’t deserve to be in that position or that, for some reason, you’re less morally virtuous (which is what Mr. Ryan seemed to be getting at) than a “blue-collar” worker.
Of all the things that Mr. Ryan said in this interview with Don Lemon that had me side-eyeing, I think that part was the worst.
And I’m a working-class (usually poor) college educated African American gay male who has seen all sides of this issue.
I wouldn’t even mention it if I didn’t read it on this site all the damn time.
I thought that all work was valuable.
I thought that all work was stressful.
I’ll tell you this.
I’ve never had a job where I didn’t have to take a shower when I got home, whether I wore a hardhat (did that a couple of times) or an apron, or I had to wear a shirt and tie (and even, occasionally, a suit).